Flies In The Ointment

The bear hug in the Rose Garden was just the icing on the cake. As foreign visits go, Prime Minister Narendra Modi바카라�s sojourn in the States was seemingly a success even before his plane touched the tarmac in Washington DC.

In anticipation of his visit, the US State Department approved the contentious sale of 22 Guardian drones manufactured by California-based General Atomics to India바카라�signalling an upswing in defence relations. On the eve of the visit, President Donald Trump바카라�s administration designa­ted Pakistan-based Hizb-ul Mujahideen chief Syed Salahuddin a 바카라�global terrorist바카라�바카라�vindicating India바카라�s stance on cross-border terror. And hours before his arrival, Trump himself tweeted that the Indian prime minister was a 바카라�true friend바카라�.

What more could Modi ask for? Not a lot, as it turned out.

Modi바카라�s two-day stay in the US reverbera­ted with hand clasps and happy talk. Bus­iness matters were high on the agenda and he met a number of American CEOs. The premier also had two meetings with the president and became the first foreign dignitary to be hosted for dinner in the Trump White House. The two leaders­ is­s­ued a joint statement, touching on trade and terrorism, in the lush greens adjacent to the Oval Office바카라�during which Modi eagerly, if awkwardly, hugged Trump.

바카라�Modi got more out of the visit than he might have expected,바카라� said Ashley Tellis, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endow­ment for International Peace.

Indeed, prior to the visit, Indo-US relations appeared to be enveloped in a cloud of uncertainty. Trump had won the presidential election last year on an 바카라�America first바카라� platform, which entailed withdrawing from international treaties and trade agreements, reducing dependence on foreign imports and focusing on the dom­estic economy. Such an approach was at odds with Modi바카라�s 바카라�Make in India바카라� mantra, which encourages Indian manufacturing and exports to markets such as the US.

Secondly, there was the question of India바카라�s relevance in the broad worldview of the new president바카라�especially in comparison with China. In his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping two months ago, Trump had indicated he was willing to let China dominate East and Southeast Asia. This, naturally, was not to India바카라�s liking, as it wants the US to keep China contained, thus allowing India more opp­ortunities to expand its diplomatic and economic footprint in the region.

Finally, just this month, Trump had pulled the US out of the two-year-old Paris global climate accord, claiming that the US had been handed an unfair deal. He had also singled India out as trying to get 바카라�billions and billions and billions of dollars in foreign aid바카라� by signing the acc­ord. The Indian foreign ministry refuted Trump바카라�s claim and called it baseless.

India had largely been off Washington바카라�s radar 바카라�in the absence of a crisis or of Ind­ian relevance to key immediate US conce­rns (North Korea, Syria) or of a cabinet member with a keen interest in India,바카라� Tanvi Madan, director of The India Project at The Brookings Institution, said in a policy brief before Modi바카라�s visit. 바카라�When the country has been in the Ame­rican spotlight, the attention has been of the unwanted kind: related to attacks against Indians, criticisms from Trump himself over climate issues, or reports on the president바카라�s businesses in India.바카라�

Given this backdrop, Modi바카라�s US visit does seem like a triumph. Madan바카라�s brief had noted that the PM바카라�s goals would be to 바카라�establish a (personal) relationship바카라� with Trump, showcase 바카라�the imp­­ortance of India, and the US-India par­­tnership바카라�, as well as shape Trump바카라�s views on regional security. In less than 48 hours, the Indian PM managed to check all these boxes.

바카라�From an Indian point of view, the visit was an astounding success,바카라� said Tellis, who has authored India바카라�s Emerging Nuclear Posture, among other books on South Asia. 바카라�The prime minister turned on the charm. The president kept his most disruptive impulses in check. That made for a personal chemistry that I think was extremely helpful.바카라�

The US move to show its solidarity with India on terrorism was quite dramatic, he added. 바카라�For India, that is the most pressing security challenge. So the things they said about combating terrorism in the joint statement and the unilateral decision by the US to designate Syed Sala­hu­d­din as a global terrorist바카라�this is nothing but good news to Indian leaders바카라� ears바카라�.

In the statement, Trump underlined the importance of the 바카라�security partnership바카라� between India and the US. 바카라�Both our nations have been struck by the evils of terrorism, and we are both determined to destroy terrorist organisations and the radical ideology that drives them. We will destroy radical Islamic terrorism.바카라� The president added that Indo-US military cooperation was also being enhanced. Tellis said this was not just rhetoric, as evident from the move to approve the sale of Guardian drones, 바카라�which we haven바카라�t done with any non-ally바카라�.

But these 바카라�wins바카라� may have come at a price. Beyond defence procurements and anti-terror cooperation, the joint statem­ent contains several red flags for India.

Trump said 바카라�it is important that barriers be removed to the export of US goods into your markets, and that we reduce our trade deficit with your country바카라�. But Indian markets have been opening to US goods for more than a quarter century now. The US trade deficit with India, at $30 billion, is less than a tenth of the US바카라� $347 billion deficit with China. While candidate Trump had, during his presidential campaign, vowed to reduce that gap, President Trump has backed down from pushing China on the matter. But his joint statement suggests that India바카라�and Modi바카라�is willing to get pushed, even though a change in the balance of trade with the US would severely exacerbate India바카라�s overall trade deficit of $13 billion.

Another red flag is Trump바카라�s hope of 바카라�exp­­orting more American energy to India바카라�. This, he said, could include 바카라�major long-term contracts to purchase Ame­ri­can natural gas바카라�. Although India바카라�s energy needs are substantial and constantly gro­­wing, they are largely met by imports from the Persian Gulf. Purch­a­ses from the US could undermine long-­standing relationships with neighbouring Arab nations, which are already threatened by India바카라�s growing intimacy with Israel.

The absence of some vital issues from the joint statement is just as alarming. One of these is the spate of violence against US-based Indians and people of Indian origin earlier this year바카라�part of a general increase in racist attacks against all people of colour following Trump바카라�s election. Another is the Trump administration바카라�s plan to make it harder for companies to bring in foreign skilled workers on H-1B visas, which are overwhelmingly used by Indian technology professionals. Both these issues have kept the Indian-American community on edge for months바카라�the statement offers little hope that the Indian government is standing up on their behalf.

Trump said in the statement that 바카라�relations between countries are strongest when they are devoted to the interests of the people we serve바카라�. But the rest of the statement indicates that바카라�under the ven­eer of Indo-US solidarity and cooperation바카라�political, corporate, and military interests are the only ones that are being served. India바카라�s obsession with scoring brownie points against Pakistan makes it value symbolic gestures바카라�like the designation of a single individual as a 바카라�global terrorist바카라�바카라�more than the pressing needs of its people. By tying its coat-tails to that of the US, it also weakens India바카라�s hand and gives other nations an undue advantage in diplomatic negotiations.

 By Saif Shahin in Ohio