Long Rope Curls Into Tight Tape

SlapGate or Dangal II, as TV channels are calling it, starts with talk about a midnight meeting. It was, the story goes, to discuss ration allocations in Delhi but the minister and secretary in charge of civil supplies are absent. IAS officer Anshu Pra­kash, chief secretary of Delhi, is summoned to chief minister Arvind Kejriwal바카라�s residence on the interven­ing night of February 19 and 20. Prakash complains to the police hours later that the meeting was just an exercise in browbeating and physical bullying. It unites the bure­aucracy across the country in anger.

Aam Aadmi Party MLAs, Prakash바카라�s police complaint states, 바카라�started shouting at me and abused me바카라� for not doing enough for publicity of the government.바카라� His description is stark: MLAs closed the door, squashed him between AAP legislator Amanatullah Khan and another MLA바카라�and demanded to know why he was not releasing the publicity spots. His refusal, citing a Supreme Court order, further inflamed the MLAs, in Prakash바카라�s version. Two nearest him 바카라�suddenly바카라�without provocation, started바카라�assaulting me and hit several blows with fists on my head and temple.바카라� He has called it a 바카라�conspiracy바카라�, a 바카라�premeditated바카라� plan.

Officers and other employees have revolted against the attack, stopping MLAs and ministers from entering the Delhi secretariat on February 21. Members of the Indian Administrative Services, Delhi Anda­man and Nicobar Islands Civil Services, Delhi Admi­nistration Subordinate Service and Prakash바카라�s cadre바카라�the Arunachal Pradesh-Goa-Mizoram and Union Territory바카라�descended on the secretariat and allegedly manhandled AAP minister Imran Hussain. A counter-complaint has been filed. Prakash Jarwal has also lodged a complaint against the bureaucrat under the SC/ST Act. Two AAP legislators, Jarwal and Amanatullah, have been arrested.

The allegation is that Jarwal and others heckled Prakash, while the AAP says the chief secretary left the meeting in a huff even as some MLAs tried to stop him. The intermittent war-like situation prevailing in Delhi between the AAP and BJP ever since the latter won 67 out of 70 seats in the assembly has reached fever pitch after the Prakash incident. Bureaucrats and other staff have refused to attend meetings of the Delhi government until Kejriwal apologises. Two hundred officials held a candlelight march in protest.

The IAS fraternity is no stranger to friction with elected representatives, but this is the first time an officer of a senior rank, chief secretary no less, is in the eye of such a storm. 바카라�Definitely something has happened at that meeting, he has been pushed, his spectacles fell off, and worse. Otherwise a chief secretary would never have complained,바카라� says IAS officer San­jay Bhoosreddy, honorary secretary of the central officers association. 바카라�That is why all associations of IAS and other adm­inistrative services and cadres have come out in support of him.바카라�

The cadres and associations demand prosecution of those involved in the attack. 바카라�You can바카라�t do in a democracy things like in goondaraj,바카라� Bhoos­reddy says. Such bullying is absolutely unacceptable and a strong signal must be sent as such by prosecuting the guilty.바카라�

Of what really happened at the meeting there obviously are two versions. According to AAP MLA from Greater Kailash Saurabh Bhardwaj, the February 19 meeting was delayed by 90 minutes because the chief secretary himself came late. 바카라�MLAs had been waiting for him since 10 p.m., the actual time fixed for the meeting,바카라� he says. (A series of weddings MLAs had to attend being the reason for the night schedule). He points out CCTV footage the AAP has released of Prakash leaving Kejriwal바카라�s residence at 11.30 p.m. 바카라�The chief secretary is saying he was beaten at the meeting, but waits 24 hours before getting a medico-l­egal test report. Why?바카라� he says. (The medical report shows Prakash had injuries on his ears, head and lips.)

Bharadwaj acknowledges Prakash left after a heated exchange and denies it came to blows. 바카라�We had expected more tension with the bureaucracy after this meeting. We never imagined a complaint of assault,바카라� he says. 바카라�If police can arrest AAP MLAs on just a complaint it should arrest those visible in CCTV footage att­acking Hussain too.바카라�

While Prakash바카라�s medico-legal examination has become a bone of contention, questions are also being raised over the AAP바카라�s claim that the meeting was about rati­ons, not publicity. 바카라�We had 11 MLAs representing Delhi바카라�s poor­est areas. The chief secretary was asked why the PDS scheme was not reaching those people. No advertisement issue was even raised,바카라� says another AAP official. 바카라�Amanatullah Khan and Prakash Jarwal were raising questions and the chief secretary told them he would only answer to the lieutenant governor,바카라� he says, calling the episode a tactic to div­ert from 바카라�growing pressure of Nirav Modi case.바카라�

바카라�Things will get worse. Delhi is in a mess,바카라� says an IAS officer. The Bharatiya Janata Party has struck out at the AAP over the incident while the Congress, initially cautious, has joined the chorus. 바카라�We also ran governments in Delhi, but never had such problems bec­ause we had a constructive app­ro­ach,바카라� says party spokesperson Manish Tiwari. 바카라�But we should be careful the government is not creating a distraction.바카라�

This is not the first time such charges have been made against the AAP. Three years ago, a senior bureaucrat had clai­med his room in the secretariat was locked. The IAS Association has complai­ned then too. The AAP바카라�s own Kumar Vishwas, the BJP바카라�s Vijender Gupta and lawyer Prashant Bhu­shan바카라�so many have alleged physical violence. Kejriwal and former L-G Naj­eeb Jung had extended spats. Appoint­ment of Delhi바카라�s IAS officials was hotly contested after Jung had claimed sole authority over it.

The question of Delhi바카라�s statehood hangs until the Supreme Court decides the matter. On a recent Sunday, the President disqualified 20 AAP legislators. Some of these episodes fuel the AAP바카라�s persecution complex. The question is, if nothing hap­pened at the February 19 meeting, then why is the chief secretary so angry.