Advertisement
X

God Finds Place In Own Country

In a land associated with 바카라godless바카라 politics, every socio-religious ­animosity is being harnessed like never before in a war for votes

Two years back, if you had asked a voter in Pala about 바카라love jehad바카라, you would have been greeted with a blank expression. It was not very much part of the political vocabulary in this neck of the woods. Pala is canonical Kottayam, a small town in this south-central district, with a slow, lilting dialect and an honest, hard-working ethic바카라you could also say it바카라s at the heart of Syrian Christian Kerala. It바카라s not as if communities in Kerala had only unbounded love for each other. Like elsewhere, there can be less than complimentary views on each other, mutual suspicions바카라and tinges of animosity. But politics here had only articulated communitarian loyalties; it never much based itself around actual antipathies. There바카라s a general balance of social forces here that gives Kerala its stability and even refinement바카라also a large social commons, so to speak, in which everyone participates. Therefore, the pathological fear of each other that defines politics in the north does not have currency here. And metaphors like love jehad, which flow such fears, never put down roots here.

And yet, there are complexities there. For one, the larger narratives of world politics have a role here. 바카라Islamophobia바카라, in the contemporary sense, is a Western construct that feeds into and plays upon older, historical India. Kerala offers a variation on that. Since the 바카라West바카라 is understood to be 바카라Christian바카라, there바카라s a natural place for affinities in thought and understanding there. So if the world out there speaks a kind of language, it is not without resonance in Pala. As astute observers have pointed out, the very category of 바카라love jehad바카라 was actually named in those terms, even created, from the heart of Christian Kerala. No surprise, then, to find that historical anxieties바카라mostly subliminal till now바카라have been brought to the surface by contemporary 바카라northern바카라 politics, of which the BJP is an exemplar. Those fears can now be seen, and heard, being expressed a bit more freely amidst the Christian community in this region.

ALSO READ:

The specific turn was imparted to things by Pala바카라s Kerala Congress (M) candidate, Jose K. Mani, when he expressed concern over the increasing incidents of 바카라love jehad바카라 that apparently targets the Christian community here. With a week to go for the assembly elections, his comments came as a huge embarrassment to the CPI(M)-led Left Democratic Front (LDF), which had allied with KC(M) just last year. The CPI(M) opposes the love jehad laws brought by some BJP-ruled states바카라its politics is naturally based around opposing, tooth and nail, the very ideas that engendered that concept. So it was naturally in a tight spot with Mani바카라s remarks, just as state BJP leaders were lapping it up. And with the Kerala Catholic Bishops바카라 Council (KCBC) extending support to Mani, things were truly on the boil.

Yes, Mani withdrew his statement the next day, but he had by then already spoken a truth. Not about love jehad, but about the deep polarisation among minority communities along religious lines ahead of the elections here. Other parties like the Indian Union Muslim League (IUML) have waded into the controversy, so expect the political landscape of Kerala to go further down this route of religious polarization, and for it to witness many more flare-ups.

Advertisement

ALSO READ:

IUML leader M.K. Muneer spoke to Outlook about the issue. The fears of the Church are baseless, he says, adding that even the Supreme Court had in a ruling refused to accord any reality to the concept of love jehad. 바카라We spoke to the bishops and tried to allay their fears. It is not happening in Kerala or elsewhere in India,바카라 says Muneer. But that only touches a different kind of verity바카라the truth is that the concept has entered the vocabulary here. The very fact that it has happened in Kerala means its social and political landscape has been coloured in a certain way바카라regardless of how well the BJP does.

Take the effects on the ground. The closing of ranks among Christians has led to a counter-mobilisation among the Muslim community ahead of the elections. 바카라If the Christians are consolidating against what they suspect to be a threat to their identity, the Muslims too are insecure about the anti-Muslim policies of the central government,바카라 observes a Calicut-based senior journalist. Observers also point out that though caste and religion play a significant role in every election, this time all the three political fronts바카라 the CPI(M)-led LDF, the Congress-led UDF and the BJP바카라have fielded their candidates purely on the basis of these considerations. To woo the Muslims in northern Kerala, the CPI(M) has also changed its tactics and incorporated more Muslim names in their candidate list바카라even going to the extent of changing a candidate after two days of campaigning, say observers.

Advertisement

ALSO READ:

Cibu Irimbinical of the KCBC, the Catholic Bishops바카라 Council, says he has never seen such inter-religious discord in an election before. 바카라This is the first time I am seeing such polarisation on religious lines. Earlier too, political parties used to consult us during elections, but this time it has gone to a different level altogether. The political parties are making sure they are not contesting along party lines, along any other aspect of politics or governance, but basing it purely on religion,바카라 he says.

For some time now, the BJP has deployed the bogey of love jehad to woo Hindu voters바카라in Kerala, this has been extended to Christian voters. In its election manifesto, it has even proposed a law against love jehad, similar to what Uttar Pradesh and other BJP-ruled states have. 바카라I feel they will use the law to harass Muslims and anyone who challenges them. We should remember that they used the same 바카라love jehad laws바카라 against the nuns who were attacked in the train at Jhansi,바카라 says Irimbinical, referring to the March 19 incident that has the potential to sour the incipient love the Church is developing for the BJP.

Advertisement

ALSO READ:

Wooing the Christian community was part of a desperate, last-ditch effort by the BJP to make inroads into Kerala, which only has a single seat in the assembly. With Kerala바카라s electoral demographic being split down three ways바카라with strong, stable Muslim and Christian populations바카라and with the 바카라Hindu vote바카라 being very riven by old caste animosities between Nairs and Ezhavas, this was an opening they had been seeking out. That the BJP바카라s Hindutva politics is based equally around a historical fear of Christianity is a just a matter of passing irony. Of late, the Christian community, a traditional vote-base of the Congress with strong anti-Marxist sentiments, has also started reciprocating with audible shows of affinity towards the BJP after the party addressed some of the concerns voiced by the community.

Keep aside the anti-Christian sentiments you will often hear on the Hindu right. Here in Kerala, the BJP was quick to capitalise on the Churches바카라 displeasure over the state government바카라s alleged appeasement policy towards Muslims, as also with the IUML바카라s increasing influence within the UDF. In an interview to Outlook, BJP state president K. Surendran said the Christians are warming up to the BJP because they see the UDF and LDF as two sides of the same coin. 바카라The Church recognises that Islamic fundamentalists are a threat to Christianity. They feel only the BJP can oppose Islamist terror,바카라 he says.

Advertisement

ALSO READ:

This works both ways, of course. It바카라s a complex chessboard. Some Christians may have started harbouring a certain affinity towards the BJP바카라on the basis of an바카라enemy바카라s enemy바카라 logic. But there is also a wariness. And the polarisation is also helping the LDF tap into minority fears바카라Muslims and Christians together comprise 46 per cent of Kerala바카라s population (Muslims: 27 per cent, Christians: 19 per cent). The impact is being felt quite strongly also in the northern districts of Kerala, where Muslims are in majority. The LDF government바카라s unwavering stand against the CAA, for instance, garnered support from among the Muslim community in the recent local body elections, says Prof Akbar C. of the Malappuram government college. Many pre-poll surveys also predict a shift in Muslim votes to the LDF camp. The minorities, who used to be a core votebank of the Congress, are moving away from the party because of its dilly-dallying on soft Hindutva and the leadership crisis, say observers.

But the BJP has sensed an opportunity amidst the growing divide between the Christian and Muslim communities. That바카라s what propelled them to intervene on a 100-year-old property dispute between two influential factions of the Church바카라the Orthodox and Jacobite Syrians. It may have inflected the political vocabulary here, but its efforts have not made much headway. Church heads held several rounds of meetings with Prime Minister Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, but not all observers are convinced about the dividends it will yield electorally. With many pre-poll surveys suggesting that the Pinarayi Vijayan government will return, a senior Kochi-based journalist says the churches may finally adopt a favourable stand towards the LDF. 바카라People know how Christians are treated by the BJP and the RSS in northern India,바카라 says CPI(M) leader and candidate M.B. Rajesh. The recent attack on two nuns on that train in Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh, feeds right into those fears and is likely to cast a shadow on the BJP바카라s hopes of garnering Christian votes. Fr Paul Thelakat, former spokesperson of the Syro-Malabar Church, for instance, is quite without doubt that the BJP and RSS were always opposed to Christianity. 바카라In Kerala, the BJP dons a different face.  There are some in the Church who consider the Syrian Christians are 바카라high castes바카라 converted to Christianity. The Hindutva forces are ready to concede that to woo them. They are even unaware of the plight of their brothers and sisters in the rest of the country,바카라 he says.

Northern Kerala is in a churn, meanwhile, and commentators say that will be a factor. It바카라s not just that many overtly Muslim outfits are in the poll fray. The CPI(M) too is hoping to breach the IUML바카라s citadel, hoping to ride on CAA and similar issues, says a party leader. Dr Hameed C., a professor at Farook College, Kozhikode, doesn바카라t think there will be any significant erosion of Muslim League votes. 바카라The IUML may retain its votebank, but there won바카라t be a total swing for the UDF like it happened during the parliamentary election,바카라 he says.

But that바카라s also a real fight, unfolding right now, to harvest souls. The animus can be gauged from the words of IUML바카라s Muneer, who says it바카라s the CPI(M) that created polarisation by spreading fake narratives, with a tacit communal angle. 바카라The CPI(M) put out the narrative that the Muslim League would end up ruling the state and that it has an upper hand in the UDF. This caused insecurity among the other communities,바카라 he says. But the IUML may perhaps have reason to worry. The CPI(M) has succeeded in improving its relationship with Sunni Muslims. And the presence of hardline Muslim outfits like the Social Democratic Party of India (SDPI) and the Jamaat-e-Islami-backed Welfare Party of India (WPI) is expected to fragment the votes even more. They have their own arguments against the Left. For instance, the LDF government바카라s move to implement a 10 per cent quota for the economically weaker sections among (Hindu) forward communities has irked some Muslims. 바카라Both the fronts have no clear stand on issues. The Left brought in economic reservations. They adopt positions only for votes,바카라 says PFI national secretary Nasaruddin Elamaram. The conflict runs deep. Hameed Vaniyambalam, state president of WPI, even says the CPI(M)바카라s stand on CAA is a fake narrative. 바카라We need an alternative anti-fascist movement,바카라 he tells Outlook.

That leaves the Hindus. There바카라s of course already a readymade topic to play on those sentiments and take care of that segment. The entry of women of all ages into the Sabarimala temple is a contentious issue of such durability that it has inevitably made a comeback in this electoral landscape, polarising the air further. All the main players want Hindu community votes바카라even if such a category had not existed earlier in Kerala, it바카라s a central feature of the ongoing polarization. Hindu votes, totalling them in a way that Kerala has not done before, comprise 55 per cent. So Sabarimala is naturally part of the induced political conversations here. Both the Congress and the BJP, in their manifesto, propose a legislation to outright ban the entry of menstruating women바카라competing almost for a more reactionary space. The LDF government, meanwhile, has taken a careful, wary stand that consultations must be held with all stakeholders after the Supreme Court바카라s ruling on the review petitions.

In numbers, the Nairs and Ezhavas make up a bulk of the Hindus in Kerala. Both are crucial elements, therefore, in this game바카라and both are politically mobilised in a way. The Sree Narayana Dharma Paripalana (SNDP) Yogam is the main socio-political organ for the originally backward caste Ezhavas; for the Nairs, largely old feudal landlords who historically resent the land reforms the Marxists brought, the Nair Service Society (NSS) is a platform. The latter바카라s position is crucial for all political fronts, and ever since the Sabarimala issue flared up, it has had a bone to pick with the LDF regime. That바카라s of course only a lens that focalises a wider spectrum of angry light. NSS general secretary G. Sukumaran Nair tells Outlook that he will keep all the parties at equal distance. 바카라Our issues shouldn바카라t be seen as political. Our demand is for banning women바카라s entry into Sabarimala and also reservation for older forward castes,바카라 he says. Caste resentment is not difficult to discern in those words.

But the Nairs comprise only 15 per cent of the population. The Ezhavas, who account for 23 per cent, are no pushovers at all바카라they have a sizeable presence among Left cadre but the SNDP has also occasionally dallied with the BJP. Vellapally Natesan, SNDP general secretary, tells Outlook that the LDF government has done stellar work in all areas, including health and education. 바카라We바카라ll help the party that helped us in crisis. The BJP won바카라t grow in Kerala even after 100 years because it바카라s a party of elite castes,바카라 he says. The SNDP바카라s political outfit, the Bharath Dharma Jana Sena (BDJS), headed by his son Tushar Vellappally, is incidentally an ally of the BJP in Kerala. Natesan바카라s words would suggest that somebody missed a trick somewhere. But that equivocation down the line shows that Kerala knows a trick or two even in these polarised times.

A shorter, edited version of this appeared in print

Show comments
KR