National

Sound Of Silence In God바카라s Court

Rumours fly as a nun바카라s ­allegation of rape by a ­bishop makes little headway

Sound Of Silence In God바카라s Court
info_icon
  • Bishops are among the most powerful ­people in the Church hierarchy, with all ­po­wer over a diocese vested in them.
  • Only the Pope has the power to defrock바카라remove from office and dismiss from holy orders바카라a Catholic bishop.
  • Franco Mulakkal is the third bishop of Jalandhar, which was elevated to the status of diocese in 1971.

***

The episcopal throne is a sturdy thing; to topple it is no simple task. The ongoing ignominy surrounding a nun바카라s claim that she was raped by the Latin Catholic (Syro-Malabar Church) bishop of Jalandhar, Franco Mulakkal, 54, has seen little progress in the criminal investigation and no internal inquiry or disciplinary proceedings ­initiated by the Church바카라amid rum­ours and acc­usations of political and monetary muscle being flexed and ranks being closed바카라and denials and counter-accusations from the alleged perpetrator, while a group of fellow nuns protest bearing red-lettered placards.

The nun joined the Jalandhar-based Missionaries of Jesus in 1994바카라a year after the congregation바카라s founding바카라aged 18. A decade later, then bishop Symp­horian Keeprath appointed her the congregation바카라s first superior general, a post she held for nine years. The numbers of the fledgling congregation have rema­ined below 100, and this hindered it from becoming an institute of ponti­fical right (under the Pope) and led to it continuing to remain one of diocesan right; that is, under the control of the bishop. After a new superior general was elected, the nun was posted to a convent in Kura­vilangadu, Kerala, which came under Mulakkal바카라s jurisdiction when he took charge as bishop of Jalandhar in 2013. On June 27 this year, she filed a police complaint바카라reportedly after being ignored by Church authorities바카라alleging that Mula­kkal had raped her at the convent 13 times between 2014 and 2016.

The bishop has responded by denying the allegations and claiming that the nun was motivated by thoughts of revenge바카라he had supposedly ordered an investigation into a complaint that she was having an affair. There have been mixed res­ponses from others in the Church, with five members of the Missionaries of Jesus, later joined by people from other Christian organisations, protesting in support of the nun, while others have accused the nun of tempting the bishop. One protester says, 바카라She [the nun] was under tremendous pressure to leave the congregation, and those of us supporting her also began to fear for our lives,바카라 adding, 바카라the bishop바카라s plan is to close down the congregation.바카라

The Kerala Latin Catholic Association, the Church바카라s official laity organisation, also wrote to the ­apo­stolic nuncio to India (the Pope바카라s representative), archbishop Giam­battista Diquattro바카라as did the nun herself바카라 and the president of the Catholic Bishops바카라 Conference of India, cardinal Oswald Gracias, pressing them to act urgently. Now in Rome, the cardinal has reportedly said that he would raise the matter with the Pope.  The nuncio is yet to say anything.

The Missionaries of Jesus congregation itself has taken its stand alongside Mulakkal, saying, 바카라We strongly condemn the protest in Kochi. We cannot crucify an innocent soul based on such allegations.바카라 Their statement goes on to say, 바카라The allegations of rape are totally baseless...She ­alleged that she was raped on May 5, 2014, but even after that, the bishop par­ticipated in functions at her house on her invitation.바카라

The police questioned Mulakkal for nine hours in August, recording his statement and seizing items, including his laptop and mobile phone바카라but did not arrest him, with an officer quoted in the press as saying, 바카라The bishop cooperated with us. We had prepared a 55-point questionnaire to record his statement. The investigation is on, and we have not arrested him as yet.바카라 Allegations of collusion between Mulakkal and the police have come from the nuns and from on  high바카라P. Kemal Pasha, a former justice of the Kerala High Court, was reported as saying, 바카라We can see a nexus between pol­ice and accused here.바카라 Protests dem­anding Mulakkal바카라s arrest continue, but there is no sign of any move so far. 

By Minu Ittyipe in Kochi

×