In India, IAS officers have been blamed for every ailment that afflicts the country바카라they are undoubtedly respÂonsible in reasonable part for both policy design and execution errÂors. But never befÂore has the country seen a good officer of chief secretary rank assaulted and abused in the presence of a chief minister. Doesn바카라t that make the CM a co-conspirator in crime, thus prove that the case is one of breakdown of governance? If it was indÂeed a meeting on rations, why at midniÂght? Why were the civil supplies minister and secretary not present?
I will simply list some facts, data and evidence바카라and leave it to the reader to judge whether the Arvind Kejriwal government in Delhi doesn바카라t warrant dismiÂssal under the Constitution to be replaced by a regime that respects rules. ConstituÂtional authorities must analyse those documented 30-odd serious violations of law from 2015 till date and then take a call on whether legally바카라not just morally바카라this government should exist or perish.
Critics of the Kejriwal government accÂuse it of four kinds of misdemeanour. First, loot the treasury and assign monetary as well as other benefits to its volunteers. Two, engage in a job generation programme바카라again, for its volunteers. Three, subvert every norm to ensure the above. Four, attribute every failure of its (mis)governance to the Union governmÂent in some manner and garner sympathy at every step. Let바카라s now see whether or not these allegations have merit.
The Aam Aadmi Party was elecÂted three years ago with huge and unprecedented aspirations of people powering it, with an educated professional leading it바카라and sadly the fall has been unprecedented too. The regime decided to interpret Delhi as a full-fledged state government. Now, that was not under the law바카라as later confirmed by the judiciary. The High Court also pointed out the supÂremacy of the lieutenant governor, appointed by PresiÂdent of India, as the administrator for Delhi. Relying on its perverse understanding and assuming existing notifications to be inoperative (which they were not in the absence of any direction from courts or the GoverÂnment of India), the Kejriwal regime went on a deeply colourable exercise of illegally grabbed authority. That was for six things: make arbitrary appointmeÂnts of unqualified persÂons (in some INSÂtances close relatiÂves of ministers); constitute/reconstitute statutory boards without authority; seek refuge in 바카라councils바카라 decisions바카라 withÂout following due process of law; exercise statutory powers that did not belong to the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi; confer benefits on the AAP, its MLAs and favoured indiÂviduals; appoint standing counsels, advocates on recÂord, et al with no process.
Numerous ex-post facto approvals were sought. That, after the hammer of High Court fell on them. Yet the Kejriwal government, self-professed 바카라anaÂrchists바카라, were determined to create disorder in public discourse and administration. First, the CM on April 29, 2015 (two-and-a-half months after assuming power), issued an order that said files pertaining to all subjects transferred to Delhi LegiÂslative Assembly as per constitutional provisions 바카라shall be decided at the appropriate level바카라 up to the CMO 바카라without bothering the offÂice of the Lt. Governor.바카라 Further, as for the reserved subjects, they should be submitted to the L-G through the minister concerned and the CM. That was in clear violation of the High Court바카라s later affirmation of the powers of the L-G in Delhi.
Second, Perfect Relations was commissioned as a consultant on a nomination basis without following bid process as per law. The PR firm created an artificial urgÂency by initiating the proposal on July 6, 2016 for a social media campaign to commence on August 8 that year. The consultant thus recommended and seleÂcted itself to execute the project! Conflict of interest be dammed!! From whom should the taxpayers바카라 money spent be recovered? Even as it was pointed out to them that this was in violation of Supreme Court guidelines and General Financial Rules manual, they went ahead.
Third, Dr Nikunj Aggarwal (Kejriwal바카라s sister-in-law바카라s son-in-law) was recruited without any due process. And he splurged public money on foreign travels and trainings. Likewise, a tender condition Clause 2D to hire 바카라highly skilled professÂionals바카라 was tweaked to allow Soni Detective & Allied Services, which proviÂdes security and housekeeping staff to also provide 바카라highly skilled professionals바카라 at huge salaries! All the expenditure was to be booked by PWD minister Satyendra Kumar Jain against 바카라Elevated Corridor for Barapullah-Phase 3바카라바카라this, after booking it against mohalla clinics fell through! Doesn바카라t tweaking the bid condition reflect criminal intent?
Fourth, hundreds of AAP party cadre and volunteers were appointed as advisors and consultants through the Delhi Dialogue Commission and Delhi ComÂmÂission for Women, besides as civil defence volunteers, in blatant violation of all norms. They had no permission of the L-G, as is required by law for any creation of post, as later confirmed by High Court as well. This was in addition to the 160 posts created co-terminus, for the offices of just seven ministers!
Fifth, deputy CM Manish Sisodia on November 28, 2017 called IAS officer Jayadev Sarangi to his office. Sisodia threatened Sarangi with dire consequences to his life, when the bureaucrat pointed out his inability to violate Supreme Court guidelines on advertising and CAG바카라s disapproval of advertorial spending. Sarangi바카라s note to the governmÂent said he, in his long career, had faced threats from land mafia, anti-Âsocial elements and terrorists, but this was for the first time he was threatened by someone holding a high constitutional authority. Can the leadership of any orgaÂnisation, in private or public sector, alienate the entÂire staff and sinews of that very entity and expect them to deliver?
Sixth, they allotted themselves a party office바카라a bungalow on Rouse Avenue바카라again in violation of all rules and despite an L-G order to vacate it after paying the rent plus penalty. They haven바카라t done so.
It바카라s time to say goodbye to this government. Nay, good riddÂance.
(The writer is an IAS officer. The views are personal.)